Podophyllin office therapy against condyloma should be abandoned
- 1Department of Dermatovenereology, Karolinska Hospital, 17176, Stockholm, Sweden
- 2Pre-clinical Development Services Ltd, Stockport, UK
- Dr von Krogh
- Accepted 22 May 2001
Podophyllin, a crude plant extract with low efficacy, high toxicity, and a serious mutagenicity profile does not comply with the WHO guidelines for plant derived treatments and should be removed from clinical treatment protocols. Home treatment with pharmaceutical products based on podophyllotoxin—the purified, standardised active antiwart ingredient of podophyllin—represents safe and effective first line therapy for patients with anogenital warts.
Patients with condylomata acuminata present to many different disciplines, and recent guidelines focus on shared management between specialists and primary care physicians.1–4 This article focuses on the advantages of purified podophyllotoxin preparations over crude podophyllin extract for safe, fast, and cost effective home treatment for condyloma eradication.
The herbal extract known as podophyllin is a crude, non-standardised, and impure resin preparation obtained from the rhizomes of the Podophyllum plant species P peltatum, or P emodi. The antiwart ingredients are antimitotically acting lignans,5 of which podophyllotoxin is the most potent.6
Kaplan7 demonstrated that topical 25% P peltatum resin extract could accomplish regression of condylomas. However, long term efficacy rates originally claimed have not been confirmed, recurrence rates being 33–55%.8 Other drawbacks include short shelf life, risk of severe local and systemic toxicity, and mutagenic properties.
QUALITY CONTROL PROBLEMS
Extraction procedures, entailing rhizome treatment with ethanol/precipitation in acidified water, do not allow for quantitative determination of constituents, which vary between batches. Toxic ingredients often cause unpredictable and severe local toxicity including painful burns and ulcerations. Podophyllin is unstable during clinic storage, with frequent crystallisation and formation of inactive picroisomers of lignans.6
Podophyllin must be applied by a trained care giver at weekly intervals. The resin must be washed off 4–6 hours after application; use of a protective inert ointment for the surrounding skin is recommended.
There is a risk of systemic intoxication, as ingredients at high concentrations may be absorbed and distributed to vital organs including the gastrointestinal mucosa, the kidneys, the bone marrow, and the CNS. Of greatest concern are the number of case reports revealing that following podophyllin painting of large condylomas, after subdermal injection into plantar warts, or following accidental ingestion, podophyllin may cause fatal or near fatal intoxication9–17 due to CNS influence, coma, respiratory depression, etc, and cardiovascular crisis. There is no known antidote. Irreversible peripheral neuropathy is a sequel in survivors. Warnings against use of volumes exceeding 0.4–0.9 ml have been issued.10
Podophyllin contains two mutagenic flavenoids, quercetin and kaempherol, which make up 3% and 6% of the dry weight, respectively18–20 and that potentially may enhance oncogenic HPV associated intraepithelial neoplasia.21
REGULATORY ASPECTS AND SAFETY EVALUATION
The WHO guidelines for evaluation of herbal remedies include tests for (1) acute toxicity; (2) long term toxicity; (3) mutagenicity and carcinogenicity; (4) reproductive toxicity; and (5) local toxicity. A formal regulatory review and safety evaluation of podophyllin has never been performed, although mutagenicity, carcinogenicity, and reproductive toxicity studies indicate that podophyllin is potentially very dangerous.22–24
A high incidence of tumours has been reported in mice exposed to podophyllin containing wood bedding.22 Podophyllin may cause chromosomal changes in hamsters23 and may be co-carcinogenic with oestrogen therapy.24 Podophyllin induces increased mutation rates in Salmonella typhimurium, numerical chromosomal defects in mammalian cell cultures, and a high incidence of chromatid and chromosome deletions, chromatid exchanges, and cells with multiple aberrations in human lymphocytes. In mice, podophyllin seems teratogenic, inducing a high frequency of fetal mortality; in rats no teratogenic influence has been demonstrated.24
LOW CLINICAL TOXICITY
In contrast with podophyllin, topical use of 0.15%–0.5% podophyllotoxin preparations are very safe for clinical use. In patients “drenching” extremely large condylomata plaques with excessive amounts of 0.5% podophyllotoxin solution, corresponding to 0.11 mg/kg as a single dose and 0.64 mg/kg as a cumulative dose, subsequent serum levels in the range of 1–17 ng/ml of podophyllotoxin have been measured. Such quantities are far below levels of clinical significance10; cancer patients receiving daily intravenous injections of 0.5–10 mg/kg podophyllotoxin have not developed any injury beyond transient bone marrow depression.25 Von Krogh10 calculated that even if a 100% podophyllotoxin absorption in theory were accomplished through accidental oral intake, up to 7 ml as a single dose would be below a level of acute toxicity.25
No washoff is required between applications6,9; local side effects from topical use of podophyllotoxin are predictable and usually mild to moderate.6,9,26 Erosions associated with successful condyloma necrosis are shallow and heal within a few days. Severe reactions such as pain requiring discontinuation of therapy are rare.
HIGH CLINICAL EFFICACY
First tested as a 0.5% ethanol solution in uncircumcised males,6,9 it appeared that podophyllotoxin therapy cycles (courses) for self treatment were feasible as twice daily application for 3 days, followed by 4–7 days of rest. Methyl-rosaniline added to taint the solution optimised compliance by enabling visualisation of treated warts. After a single course, 70% of preputial sac warts and 49% of all penile warts were eradicated. When another therapy course was prescribed, 82% of cases were cured at 3 months' follow up. In subsequent European key studies,9,26–30 cumulative long term (3–4 months' follow up) results following podophyllotoxin home therapy has consistently been more effective than podophyllin office therapy (p <0.05–0.001; table 1). The currently licensed 0.5% podophyllotoxin solution containing patent blue as a colour indicator, is convenient for penile warts; the foreskin is retracted and the solution is applied to each wart using a specially designed plastic applicator or cotton wool swabs.
With the exception of a few early US based studies31,32 when compliance problems might have existed because of use of a colourless podophyllotoxin solution, well controlled studies on the cyclical use of 3 day courses of a 0.5% podophyllotoxin tainted solution in women have also shown good therapeutic effects against vulval warts, with clearance rates being in the range of 50%–77%.26,33,34 In recent years, the compliance aspect of podophyllotoxin treatment has been improved through the development of a white coloured 0.15% cream (Wartec, Warticon) to be rubbed into vulval and anal wart areas by the patient's index finger, following physician guided office information on their location and by self inspection through a hand held mirror. Randomised prospective studies (table 1) demonstrate that the 0.15% cream is generally as effective as the 0.5% tainted solution. Thus, Lacey et al 26 showed that all original warts disappeared in 78% of patients given the cream versus in 58% of podophyllin treated patients (p<0.01) and that the long term cure rate was highly superior in the favour of the cream versus that of 25% podophyllin (59% versus 46%; p<0.001). Cost calculations show that although podophyllin is cheap to produce, it is less cost effective when compared with podophyllotoxin home therapy.26
REGULATORY ASPECTS AND EXPERIMENTAL SAFETY EVALUATIONS
The licensed 0.15–0.5% podophyllotoxin products have been assessed in terms of chemistry, pharmacology, and toxicology. The experimental toxicology data, published in further detail elsewhere,24 are briefly compiled in the current survey.
Oral bioavailability in dogs following high doses (1.0 mg/kg) is up to 63% compared with intravenous administration, peak plasma levels occurring at 1–8 hours followed by a sharp decline and with only trace amounts detectable at 24 hours. Only doses of 1.0 mg/kg cause detectable CNS levels at 2–8 hours. In mice, both kidney and biliary excretion occurs; after 24 hours all organs and body fluids with the exception of the liver, the intestines, and urine are cleared. In pregnant mice, podophyllotoxin may reach higher concentrations in fetal than in maternal organs such as the bone marrow, spleen, thymus, lymph glands, and the dental pulp/dentine edge.
Carcinogenicity and genotoxicity
Rats and mice receiving up to 0.3 mg/kg/day of podophyllotoxin in the diet for 104 and 80 weeks, respectively, have not shown any evidences of an oncogenic effect. In Salmonella typhimurium podophyllin induced up to 13.6-fold increase in revertant numbers, while podophyllotoxin exposure merely resulted in a 1.5–1.6-fold increase attributed to chance with no dose relation.
PHA stimulated human lymphocyte cultures exposed to podophyllotoxin for 25 hours did not show any clastogenic effect. No mutagenic potential has been detected in ovarian and lymphoma cell cultures, and no single strand DNA breakage has been detected in human cell cultures.
Local sensitisation potential
In the guinea pig maximisation test 0.1 % and 0.5% podophyllotoxin preparations caused toxic reactions associated with the cutaneous necrosis but did not show any immunological sensitising properties.35
Podophyllotoxin is not teratogenic to rats or rabbits. Pregnant rats and their offspring were followed after oral administration of 0.4, 1.0, or 2.5 mg/kg/day podophyllotoxin from the 15th day of gestation to the 21st day post partum. There were no influences on fertility, gestation, mating, litter size, embryonic or fetal development, or perinatal and postnatal behaviour. A negative influence was observed in the offspring exposed to the highest dose (2.5 mg/kg) regarding survival rate, as well as delayed development and weight gain of survivors. There was no influence in exposed animals on the rate of malformations, birth weight, behaviour, or on fertility or mating in podophyllotoxin exposed mothers or in their first/second generation offspring.
Although reproductive toxicity studies in animals have not shown teratogenicity and the half life appears to be short and systemic elimination occurs within a few days, we still believe that podophyllotoxin should be avoided during pregnancy since the possibility cannot be excluded that the drug might accumulate in the human fetus. As a further precaution, we also recommend that conception should be avoided during the week following completion of podophyllotoxin therapy.
Use of the crude herbal remedy podophyllin is associated with low production costs, but the cost benefit versus the risk ratio of the product is highly questionable. Further podophyllin use is not only redundant but should be abandoned in favour of its modern pharmaceutical replacement—that is, podophyllotoxin preparations with well defined pharmacokinetic, metabolic, and toxicity safety profiles. Podophyllotoxin solution and cream have been documented as safe and effective for self therapy of anogenital warts (table 2) and are recommended as first line therapy.