Objectives In 2006, a new variant of Chlamydia trachomatis (nvCT) was discovered in Sweden. It has a deletion in the plasmid resulting in failed detection by the single target systems from Abbott and Roche used at that time, whereas the third system used, from Becton Dickinson (BD), detects nvCT. The proportion of nvCT was initially up to 65% in counties using Abbott/Roche systems. This study analysed the proportion of nvCT from 2007 to 2015 in four selected counties and its impact on chlamydia-associated complications.
Methods C. trachomatis-positive specimens collected from 2007 to 2015 were analysed by a specific PCR to identify nvCT cases. Genotyping was performed by multilocus sequence typing (MLST) and ompA sequencing. Ectopic pregnancy and pelvic inflammatory disease records were extracted from the national registers.
Results In total, 5101 C. trachomatis-positive samples were analysed. The nvCT proportion significantly decreased in the two counties using Roche systems, from 56% in 2007 to 6.5% in 2015 (p<0.001). In the two counties using BD systems, a decrease was also seen, from 19% in 2007 to 5.2% in 2015 (p<0.001). Fifteen nvCT cases from 2015 and 102 cases from 2006 to 2009 had identical MLST profiles. Counties using Roche/Abbott systems showed higher mean rates of ectopic pregnancy and pelvic inflammatory disease compared with counties using BD systems.
Conclusions The nvCT proportion has decreased in all counties and converged to a low prevalence irrespective of previous rates. Genotyping showed that nvCT is clonal and genetically stable. Failing detection only marginally affected complication rates.
- chlamydia trachomatis
- pelvic inflammatory disease
- ectopic pregnancy
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
A new variant of Chlamydia trachomatis (nvCT) was discovered in Sweden in 2006.1 nvCT has a deletion in its plasmid that included the target sequences used by two diagnostic single target nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs) at that time, Abbott m2000 (Abbott Laboratories, Des Plaines, Illinois, USA) and Amplicor/COBAS Amplicor/TaqMan48 (Roche, Molecular Systems, Branchburg, New Jersey, USA). The proportion of nvCT was between 20% and 65% in counties using these Abbott/Roche NAATs in 2006.2 Retrospective analysis showed nvCT was present already in 20033 and a conservative calculation estimates the number of false-negative tests to 15 000 in Sweden from 2003 to 2006, that is, when nvCT was undetected. Abbott and Roche subsequently designed dual-target assays that could detect also nvCT. The third NAAT used in Sweden at that time was ProbeTec from Becton Dickinson (BD, Franklin Lakes, New Jersey, USA). This NAAT has always been able to detect nvCT because it uses another target region on the plasmid. The proportion of nvCT in counties using the BD NAAT ranged from 7% to 19% in 2006–2007.2
The objectives of the present study were (1) to determine the current nvCT prevalence (2015) and relate it to the prevalence in previous years; (2) to analyse if the nvCT is of clonal nature; and (3) to investigate available records of chlamydia-associated complications between 2000 and 2014 and associate it with the nvCT prevalence and diagnostic methods used.
Materials and methods
Study populations and detection methods
Two counties using Roche NAAT for detection of C. trachomatis, and two counties using BD NAAT in 2006 were selected. The Roche counties Dalarna and Örebro counties had the highest reported nvCT rate in 20062 and were therefore important to follow over time. The Uppsala county is a neighbour to several Abbott/Roche counties and showed the influx of nvCT into an area using the BD system, while the BD county Norrbotten is remote and had no neighbour county using Abbott/Roche diagnostics in 2006. In the two Roche counties, the COBAS TaqMan48 NAAT was replaced by ompA-based NAATs in November 2006 and January 2007, respectively. The new dual target version COBAS TaqMan CT Test v2.0, which detects nvCT, was implemented in mid-2008. The study periods in the four counties are shown in online supplementary table 1.
Supplementary Table 1
Mainly consecutive C. trachomatis-positive specimens (one per patient) were collected in each county in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011 and 2015. The time periods differed between counties from 30 to 90 days from November 2006 to April 2007. In the other years, collection periods varied from 60 to 147 days from January to July. The length of collection periods was chosen to show differences in nvCT proportion between counties using Roche and BD NAATs. DNA extraction methods for the years 2007–2009 have been described earlier,4 and evaluations have shown that the change of DNA extraction method in the two Roche counties did not have any considerable impact on C. trachomatis detection when compared with the Roche NAAT used until 2006.
Specific detection of nvCT and wild-type C. trachomatis was based on size differentiation in a PCR method targeting the plasmid by use of primers from a method by Ripa and Nilsson,5 as previously described.4 After exclusion of non-typeable cases, we calculated differences in proportions of nvCT with 95% CIs and compared them using a χ2 test (Minitab Statistical Software V.17; Minitab, State College, Pennsylvania, USA).
Logistic regression was used to evaluate proportions of nvCT of all detected C. trachomatis cases as a relative linear trend expressed as OR per year measured in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011 and 2015 and furthermore evaluate if the relative trends per year were different between counties using Abbott/Roche and BD by interaction tests. Poisson regression was used to compare rates of ectopic pregnancy and pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) between counties using Abbott/Roche and BD C. trachomatis detection systems.
The genetic stability of nvCT was analysed by sequence determination of ompA and five multilocus sequence typing (MLST) genes as described in the protocol available at http://mlstdb.bmc.uu.se/.
Chlamydia-associated complication episodes
The numbers of reported C. trachomatis cases in all Swedish counties were obtained from The Public Health Agency of Sweden. C. trachomatis infections are included in the Swedish Communicable Diseases Act and are mandatory to report. The statistics on PID and ectopic pregnancy from 2000 to 2014 (inpatient diagnoses) and from 2005 to 2014 (outpatient diagnoses), and number of births (including stillbirths) were obtained from The National Patient Register, The National Board of Health and Welfare (http://www.socialstyrelsen.se/statistik/statistikdatabas). All diagnoses of ectopic pregnancy (International Classification of Disease 10th Revision codes corresponding to ICD 10 O00) and PID (N70, 71, 73) were included. Data on number of women in different counties were retrieved from Statistics Sweden (http://www.scb.se/en).
In total, 5101 samples were analysed, of which 286 (5.6%) were untypeable and excluded from the study. The number of samples ranged from 115 to 377 per year from each county (see online supplementary table 1). All counties showed a significant decrease in the proportion of nvCT from 2007 to 2015 expressed as OR per year; however, the nvCT proportion in the counties using Roche NAAT decreased significantly more compared with the counties using BD NAAT (p<0.01, interaction test). In the two Roche counties combined, the proportion of nvCT was 56% in 2007 and the decrease showed an OR of 0.71 (95% CI 0.68 to 0.74) per year, resulting in an nvCT proportion of 6.5% in 2015. In the two counties using BD NAAT combined, the proportion of nvCT was 19% in 2007 and the decrease showed an OR of 0.82 (95% CI 0.78 to 0.86) per year, resulting in an nvCT proportion of 5.3% in 2015.
Separate analysis of the two BD counties showed contrasting trends. In Norrbotten, there was an initial increase from 9% in 2007 to 19% in 2009 and thereafter a continuous decline in the nvCT proportion. In Uppsala, there was an overall decline from 24% in 2007, followed by 27% in 2008 and then a continuous fall to 5.4% in 2015. The difference in nvCT proportion between the two Roche counties and the two BD counties was obvious in 2008, but was not significant in 2009 (Roche counties 24% (97/405); BD counties 18% (72/391), figure 1A). In 2011, the nvCT proportion remained at 24% (98/404) in the Roche counties but declined to 11% (64/559) in the BD counties; this difference of 13% was significant (95% CI 11, 15%, p<0.001). In 2015, the difference had decreased to 1.3% (Roche counties 6.5% (43/666); BD counties 5.2% (37/697)). Detailed information is given in online supplementary table 2A.
Supplementary Table 2
The proportion of nvCT was compared by age (see online supplementary table 2B). The individuals infected with nvCT were initially younger in counties using Roche NAAT, both in 2007 and 2008, but not in 2009 and 2011 (data not shown). In 2015, the proportion of nvCT was significantly higher in the age group ≥30 years in the Roche counties (p<0.001). In counties using BD NAAT, nvCT was not significantly associated with age group at any time point. No difference in the proportion of nvCT was seen between the genders (data not shown).
The total number of C. trachomatis cases per 100 000 inhabitants, diagnosed from January 2007 to June 2007, was higher in Dalarna than in the other counties (figure 1B). The incidence in Dalarna declined dramatically in 2008; and thereafter the differences between the four counties were reduced and were not associated with diagnostic method. National C. trachomatis rates show that since 1997, the number of diagnostic tests used and cases detected increased (figure 2). The number of detected cases in 2005 (n=33 162) and 2006 (n=32 513) was substantially affected by the failure to detect nvCT. Thereafter, a transient increase was seen in 2007 (n=47 103), when C. trachomatis NAATs detecting nvCT were implemented. In recent years, the C. trachomatis rates have levelled off and nvCT has no visible impact on national statistics.
The genetic stability was analysed and 15 nvCT cases from 2015 (6 from Roche counties; 9 from BD counties) were identical in the 5 MLST genes as well as in ompA.
The number of reported ectopic pregnancies per 1000 births in the age group 15–39 years differed when the 13 counties using Abbott or Roche NAATs in 2006 were compared with the eight counties using the BD NAAT for C. trachomatis detection (figure 3A). During the years 2000–2014, the hospitalised mean rate was 1.06 (95% CI 1.03 to 1.09) times higher in counties using Abbott/Roche compared with counties using BD, and more pronounced in the first 8 years (2000–2007), relative risk (RR) 1.09 (95% CI 1.05 to 1.13), than the latter years, RR 1.02 (95% CI 0.98 to 1.07). The outpatients mean rate was also significantly higher in the years 2005–2014, RR 1.12 (95% CI 1.08 to 1.17). The mean rate of the hospitalised PID/100 000 women aged 15–39 years was 1.03 (95% CI 1.00 to 1.06) and the outpatient mean rate was 1.10 (95% CI 1.07 to 1.13) times higher in Abbott/Roche counties compared with BD counties (figure 3B).
The proportion of nvCT in 2006–2007 was reported to be considerably higher in counties using Abbott/Roche NAATs than in counties using BD NAAT.2 The present study shows that the nvCT proportion rapidly decreased in Roche counties after re-establishment of NAATs detecting nvCT. In the following years, the proportions of nvCT converged in all four counties and are now on the same low level. Genotyping showed that the nvCT emergence was of clonal nature. Despite severe failures in C. trachomatis detection capacity for some years, the appearance of nvCT had a statistically significant but limited effect on the rates of chlamydia-associated complications.
A main strength of our study is its design allowing the nvCT rates to be followed in selected counties in Sweden over a long time period. As briefly mentioned above, the Dalarna and Örebro counties had the highest reported nvCT rate in 20062 and were therefore important to follow over time. The Uppsala county is a neighbour to several Abbott/Roche counties and showed the influx of nvCT into an area using the BD system, while the Norrbotten county is remote and had no neighbour county using Abbott/Roche diagnostics in 2006. Limitations in the present study are the relatively low number of analysed samples in the individual counties and in specific age groups, as well as that our studied counties might not in detail reflect the situation in all Swedish counties. Population movements between counties may also affect the representativeness of the numbers in the study. However, for the 15–44 year age group only 4% moved between Swedish counties in any of the study years. Thus, this limitation had no impact on the main conclusion of decreasing and converging nvCT rates.
The decreasing nvCT rates are not surprising considering the loss of the selective diagnostic advantage when appropriate detection methods were reintroduced. This is also supported by the unaltered biological fitness reported for nvCT.6 The emergence of nvCT created Sweden into a natural experiment to see what happen when opportunistic chlamydia screening was ‘stopped.’ Obviously, chlamydia infections were increasingly spread when testing failed and subsequent treatment and mandatory partner notification diminished. Thus, if Sweden not had its policy of widespread testing for decades, chlamydia rates would probably have been even higher. After reintroduction of adequate detection methods chlamydia rates first increased sharply and thereafter levelled off.
We have earlier shown that the spread of nvCT is of clonal nature. This is further confirmed in the present study where the strains from 2015 were identical in the five MLST target genes with 102 nvCT strains from 2006 to 2009.2–4 7 The only difference was seen in 2007 when the additionally examined gene ompA in two related cases differed by a single nucleotide polymorphism. These results also show that the MLST scheme used is sufficiently stable over time, a prerequisite for reliable genotyping. This also confirms the stability previously shown both in laboratory experiments and in previous studies of lymphogranuloma venereum.8 Whole genome sequencing would increase the resolution; however, it would not change the main conclusion regarding the clonal nature of nvCT. Accordingly, considering the cost and especially the technical challenges to obtain complete C. trachomatis genomes with high coverage from clinical samples, we did not find it essential to perform such an analysis in our study.
Except from Norway, nvCT has been reported as absent or only a few cases have been detected in studies from several European countries.2 7 9–14 This limited spread might partly be explained by the fact that sexual contacts are mostly living within a short distance and are only rarely long-distance contacts.15 Accordingly, sexual networks of risk groups for the nvCT within Sweden (mostly young heterosexual men and women) may be localised and thus only reach outside the country to a limited extent. This explanation is also supported by the fact that nvCT is a genotype E strain, a variant that rarely has been found in networks of men who have sex with men, which are frequently large and stretch more internationally. An additional explanation is the NAATs used in neighbouring countries. For example, in Denmark Abbott/Roche NAATs comprised about 30% of the C. trachomatis NAATs in 2007, and substantially less in the Copenhagen area with the closest interaction with Sweden.16 Norway is the only country that has reported notable numbers of nvCT, which accounted for 3% of C. trachomatis cases detected by a BD NAAT in 2008.17 Considering that 20% of the age group 17–25 years in the capital Oslo are Swedes, this indicates that nvCT has been imported to Norway, but it has not spread dramatically.
Considering an estimated number of 8000 false-negative C. trachomatis tests due to nvCT in 2005–200618 or 15 000 false-negative tests in 2003–2006, which are substantial proportions of all positive cases in Sweden, there is reason to suspect an elevated number of complication episodes such as PID and ectopic pregnancy, at least in counties that used Roche/Abbott NAATs in 2006. In such counties, higher mean rates of complications were also seen compared with counties using BD NAAT. A limitation of the study is that the national register is incomplete. However, on average 87% of patient visits and linked diagnoses are reported to The National Patient Register, The National Board of Health and Welfare (Anders Jacobsson, personal communication). Therefore, the obtained figures can be assumed to mirror the real situation. Another limitation for analysis is that C. trachomatis infections are responsible for only a fraction of all complications. In recent studies, the population excess fraction of PID due to C. trachomatis infections was between 20% and 30%19 and for ectopic pregnancy not more than 10%,20 which decrease the possibility to see an impact of nvCT on complication rates. The time gap between chlamydia infection, with eventual PID, and the conception leading to ectopic pregnancy varies for individuals, which also affects the possibility of observing an effect of nvCT on complication rates. It would have been preferable to correlate C. trachomatis rates to complication rates directly in the four study counties, but the low number of complication episodes in the individual counties would not enable a meaningful analysis. Hence, national figures were used instead. The management of PID cases has changed over time and patients have been less often hospitalised in recent years, which also affect the number of reported cases. On the other hand, the incompleteness of reporting and the changes in management are the same in both categories of counties
A retrospective study following individuals, like a comprehensive study in Denmark,21 would increase the strength to investigate the impact of nvCT on complication rates, but it is impossible to collect the necessary data in Sweden. It would be more feasible with a modelling study of the spread of nvCT and its impact on associated complications. Altogether, the low number of registered complication episodes in the present study indicates that the risk of acquiring C. trachomatis-associated complications is lower than generally considered and is in agreement with our previous study22 and also with recent modelling studies.23 The increasing support for a low risk of complications caused by C. trachomatis infections might stress the need for new evaluations of the policy with widespread chlamydia testing as in Sweden and other countries.
In summary, nvCT spread rapidly in Sweden in the years before the discovery in 2006, but the rates decreased after changes to adequate detection methods in counties that used Abbott/Roche diagnostics at that time point. The nvCT proportion of all C. trachomatis cases has now converged to a low level irrespective of detection system used. The appearance of nvCT has only marginally affected the rates of C. trachomatis-associated complications in Sweden.
Due to failing detection methods, the new variant of Chlamydia trachomatis (nvCT) spread rapidly in Sweden in the years before the discovery in 2006.
The nvCT rates have declined to a low level in 2015, irrespective of previously used detection methods.
The C. trachomatis-associated complications were higher in counties using failing detection systems in 2006, but the spread of nvCT had only a marginal effect on the complication rates in Sweden.
Handling editor Jackie A Cassell
Contributors BH, HF and MU designed the study; BH, KE, IL, HF and MU coordinated the study and all surveillance sites; JD, JI and RH performed all the laboratory work; JD, RH and BH performed the initial data analysis; AM performed statistical analysis; JD and BH, with support of RH, HF and MU, wrote the first draft of manuscript. All authors contributed to the finalisation of the manuscript.
Funding This work was supported by grants from local funds at Uppsala University Hospital and from the Örebro County Council Research Committee and the Foundation for Medical Research at Örebro University Hospital, Sweden.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethics approval The study was approved by the Regional Ethical Review Board in Uppsala, Sweden (Dnr2007/312).
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.