Table 3 Potential benefits and challenges of different models of family planning/HIV service integration
Type of integration modelPotential benefitsPotential challenges
Family planning into HIV counselling and testing
  • Reaches the largest number of clients of any HIV service

  • Reaches both HIV+ and HIV− clients

  • Reaches men, youth and unmarried women who may not use traditional family planning programmes

  • Opportunity for all clients to avoid initial or subsequent unintended pregnancy

  • VCT typically provides only a one-time contact with client

  • HIV+ clients may not be ready to absorb family planning messages

  • Requires referral systems, which are often weak, for initial supply, resupply and follow-up for complications and side effects

Family planning into PMTCT
  • Reaches clients of reproductive age with high probability of future pregnancy and with known HIV+ status

  • Most PMTCT clients are reached during antenatal care, a time when family planning messages may not resonate with clients

  • Difficulties reaching women in the postpartum period and beyond for follow-up family planning services

Family planning into care and treatment
  • Reaches only HIV+ clients, thereby maximising opportunities to prevent HIV+ births

  • Repeat visits allow for repeated messages, resupply, follow-up for complications/side effects and to meet changing fertility desires

  • Unmet need may be lower because clients may be older, ill, and/or not sexually active compared with clients in other HIV services

HIV services into family planning
  • May create new contraceptive users if the availability of the HIV services attracts clients who do not typically access family planning services

  • May not reach those at high risk of HIV infection

  • May increase uptake of HIV services among family planning clients, particularly VCT services, thereby allowing providers to tailor contraceptive counselling based on client’s HIV status

  • Opportunity for HIV prevention counselling among women of reproductive age

  • The additional financial resources for HIV services may bolster existing family planning staff and facilities

  • Availability of more comprehensive services and support for family planning clients may help improve contraceptive adherence and continuation

  • PMTCT, prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV; VCT, Voluntary Counselling and Testing.