Knowledge and attitudes of health professionals toward adolescent health care

doi:10.1016/0197-0070(90)90037-3

Journal of Adolescent Health Care

Volume 11, Issue 4, July 1990, Pages 289-294

Journal of Adolescen...

https://doi.org/10.1016/0197-0070(90)90037-3 Get rights and content

Abstract

The rising concern over the competency of health care professionals in the United States to meet the health needs of adolescents was the impetus for a national survey of 3066 physicians, nurses, social workers, nutritionists, and psychologists. The survey explored perceptions of training and competency regarding 16 dimensions of adolescent health care. Major deficits were noted for each discipline. For physicians, self-perceived limitations were in the areas of eating disorders, learning disabilities, chronic illness, and delinquent behavior. The same limitations were also mentioned by nurses. Over half of the psychologists reported deficits related to the psychological sequelae of sexual concerns, sexual orientation conflict, eating disorders, and chronic illness. Many of the same concerns reflected the perceived competencies of social workers. Nearly half of all nutritionists surveyed acknowledged deficits in almost all adolescent food-related concerns. The impact of these low levels of perceived competency is discussed in terms of implications for clinical service.

References (17)

M Story et al.
Adolescent nutrition: self-perceived deficiencies and needs of practitioners working with youth
J Am Diet Assoc
(1988)
A Marks et al.
Assessment of health needs and a willingness to utilize health resources of adolescents in a suburban population
J Pediatr
(1983)
R Blum et al.
Training and education issues in adolescent health
R Blum
Physicians' assessment of deficiencies and desire for training in adolescent health care
J Med Educ
(1987)
B Starfield et al.
Psychosocial and psychosomatic diagnoses in primary care of children
Pediatrics
(1980)
P Grahm et al.
Training of pediatricians for psychosocial aspects of their work
Arch Dis Child
(1985)
J Rosenthal et al.
Divergent pediatric continuing medical education priorities in a rural area
J Med Educ
(1982)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (87)

How do underserved adolescents want to learn about health? An exploration of health concerns, preferences, and resources utilized
2022, Journal of the National Medical Association
Citation Excerpt :
Despite numerous barriers to healthcare access, we found that adolescents in our study indicated a preference to learn about health topics from providers/doctors. Yet many health providers report feeling inadequately trained to meet the needs of adolescents.17 Our findings also suggest there is a paucity of trauma/violence education provided to this group of adolescents who are disproportionately affected by trauma and violence.
Understanding health concerns and preferences of underserved adolescents has potential to shape health interventions. The objective of this study is to better understand these adolescents’ current and preferred health resources, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. High school students from underrepresented communities in six US cities completed a pre-pipeline program survey in which they reported level of personal concern, as well as current and preferred sources of information about 1) depression/anxiety, 2) nutrition, 3) sexual health, 4) trauma/violence, and 5) alcohol/drugs. 259 participants completed the survey (avg. age 15.7, 79% female, 58.3% Hispanic, and 36.0% Black). At least a moderate level of concern and some degree of prior knowledge (>3 on 5-point Likert scale) were reported across all health topics. Participants reported the lowest level of knowledge on the topic of trauma/violence. Students reported family (24%) and teachers (21%) as the most utilized current sources of information. Students reported doctors as the preferred source of information across all health topics. The difference between students’ current source of information and preferred source of information was significant across four topics: depression/anxiety, sexual health, trauma, and alcohol/drugs (p <0.01). These results underscore the important role of physicians as educators and suggest a need for improved education on trauma/violence. These results also establish a pre-COVID-19 baseline for adolescent health concerns, current, and preference health resources. This baseline understanding may shift because of pandemic changes.
Perception of adolescent medicine among French pediatric residents
2016, Archives de Pediatrie
Peu d’études explorent comment les futurs pédiatres se représentent la médecine de l’adolescent (MA) alors qu’ils y seront confrontés. Ce travail avait pour objectif principal de recueillir les représentations de la MA auprès de futurs pédiatres et pour objectif secondaire de préciser leurs besoins en termes de formation. Un questionnaire déclaratif électronique a été diffusé via l’Association des juniors de pédiatrie (AJP) aux internes de pédiatrie ayant validé 6 semestres. Ce questionnaire, composé de 51 questions, explorait leur caractéristiques démographiques et leur formation pratique en MA ; leur représentations de la MA ; et les besoins ressentis en termes de formation. Cent vingt et un internes ont répondu à l’enquête (taux de réponse 43 %). Les adolescents étaient perçus comme intéressants (75 %) et chronophages (84 %). Quatre cinquième des répondants considéraient qu’une formation spécifique à la MA était nécessaire. Les internes jugeant cette formation inutile étaient ceux qui n’avaient pas pratiqué de stage hospitalier en MA. Un enseignement dédié à la MA avait été proposé à moins de la moitié des internes (45 %). Un tiers des répondants avait effectué un stage d’au moins 2 mois dans une unité de MA. Former les futurs pédiatres à la MA est une priorité en matière de santé publique. Le référentiel de compétences dans ce champ de la pédiatrie doit être articulé avec l’identification de terrains de stages hospitaliers et extra-hospitaliers. À l’heure de la réforme du troisième cycle une mobilisation de la pédiatrie s’impose.
The perception of adolescent medicine (AM) among future pediatricians in France has scarcely been explored although adolescent health care is an integral part of the pediatrician's job. Moreover, pediatric residents seem to have a lack of enthusiasm for this field. The aim of this study was to assess the beliefs and perceptions of fourth-year French pediatric residents regarding adolescents and AM.
We conducted a national electronic survey among French pediatric residents in their last year of residency. An original 51-item, open-ended declarative questionnaire was sent out including questions on demographics, career expectations, AM block rotation experiences, and perceptions and beliefs regarding adolescents and AM. Difficulties and barriers experienced in this field were investigated. Queries about residents’ specific AM courses and about their educational needs were also explored.
The survey was conducted online between January and March 2015. There were 121 respondents, achieving a 43% response rate. The majority of respondents perceived teens as interesting (75%), vulnerable (83%), and time-consuming (84%). Up to four fifths of respondents (81%) considered AM to be a skill that all pediatricians should acquire. A subgroup analysis showed that the residents who had not experienced an AM block rotation did not seem to be convinced of the need for training in this field (P = 0.09). The following issues were reported as major difficulties by residents: providing care for teens reluctant to seek health care (65%), managing violent behavior among adolescents in the emergency ward (98%), and managing adolescents who attempt suicide (80%). Less than half (45%) of the residents reported their residency program had a specific AM course. Among them, 73% attended the lectures and 57% found them useful. One third (32%) of the respondents had experienced a 2-month block rotation in the field of AM during their residency.
This is the first nationwide study in France in this field. Although the response rate is below 50%, it exceeded our expectations. Our results are in line with previous studies showing that pediatric residents report a high interest in working with adolescents and yet their educational needs in AM are unmet. The limitations of this study include the self-selection bias and implicit limitations carried by the phrasing of the survey questions.
There is a need to devise a better educational approach combining a broader proposal of AM block rotations together with a specific competency framework in adolescent health, since we know it improves the quality of health care delivered to adolescents. Moreover, training pediatricians in AM is a public health priority so as to comply with medical schools’ principles of social accountability and address the priority health needs for an efficient, equitable, and sustainable health system. At a time when postgraduate reform is being made, the inclusion of an AM curriculum in the general pediatrician course is necessary.
Use of a standardized patient paradigm to enhance proficiency in risk assessment for adolescent depression and suicide
2012, Journal of Adolescent Health
Although routine adolescent depression and suicide risk assessment (ADSRA) is recommended, primary care physician (PCP) ADSRA training is needed for successful ADSRA implementation. This study examined the effect of an intervention using standardized patients (SPs) on PCP ADSRA confidence, knowledge, and practices.
The intervention consisted of a 60-minute seminar followed by a 60-minute SP session to practice ADSRA skills in simulated clinical situations.
PCPs (n = 46) completed pre- and postintervention assessments. Untrained PCPs interested in the intervention (n = 58) also completed assessments. Assessments evaluated ADSRA self-reported confidence and practices and objectively assessed knowledge. The main outcomes were (1) changes in pre-/postintervention PCP ADSRA confidence and knowledge, and (2) ADSRA practices in untrained versus postintervention PCPs.
Compared with untrained PCPs, PCPs 5–10 months postintervention were more likely to screen most adolescents for depression (40% vs. 22%, p = .05), to use a depression screening tool (50% vs. 19%, p = .001), to have diagnosed at least one adolescent with depression in the past 3 months (96% vs. 78%, p = .013), and to have screened depressed adolescents for suicide risk factors, including access to weapons (51% vs. 25%; p = .007) or an impulsive violence history (27% vs. 11%; p = .037). PCP confidence and knowledge about depression assessment and treatment also significantly improved postintervention.
This study supports the use of an SP intervention to improve PCP ADSRA confidence, knowledge, and practices. Widespread implementation of similar educational efforts has the potential to dramatically improve adolescent morbidity and mortality.
Principles of adolescent-and youngadult-friendly care: Contributions to reducing health disparities and increasing health equity
2023, Perspectives on Health Equity and Social Determinants of Health
Frontline Medical Professionals' Ability to Recognize and Respond to Suspected Youth Sex Trafficking
2023, Pediatric Emergency Care
Adolescent medicine training in postgraduate family medicine education: a scoping review
2023, International Journal of Adolescent Medicine and Health

View all citing articles on Scopus

^☆: This study supported in part by grants MCJ-000985 and MCJ-009069, Department of Health anf Human Services, Public Health Service, Health Resurces and Services Administration Bureau of Health Care Delivery and Assistance, Division of Meternal and Child Health.

View full text

Original articleKnowledge and attitudes of health professionals toward adolescent health care☆

Abstract

J Am Diet Assoc

J Pediatr

Training and education issues in adolescent health

Physicians' assessment of deficiencies and desire for training in adolescent health care

J Med Educ

Psychosocial and psychosomatic diagnoses in primary care of children

Pediatrics

Training of pediatricians for psychosocial aspects of their work

Arch Dis Child

Divergent pediatric continuing medical education priorities in a rural area

J Med Educ

Original article
Knowledge and attitudes of health professionals toward adolescent health care☆